I gave it a 9 because I have not worn it yet and only tried it on rapidly. I took the recommended size. It seems abit It snug on me around the waist and top area and long for my height but denim stretches as we wear it and shrinks if we wash it. It might work for me because I really like this dress. It looks just like the product images and the pricewas nice compared to other dresses of the same sort. It Seems like good quality denim heavy not flimsy material. Just like it should be. Well made, no extra threads sticking out of the garment. No bad dmell just denim fabric smell. The color is great.